From time to time this issue comes up - especially after a, roadtraffic accident 'caused' by an elderly driver. I fully understand the feeling when someone's loved one is a victim of such an accident.
There is no solid evidence that people beyond a certain arbitrary age, become unsafe and irresponsible drivers! Of course there must be proper vetting of disabled and handicapped drivers , with illnesses and conditions influencing dexterity, consciusness and affecting decision making process. Such 'vetting' does already exist and most responsible motorists , old and young, abide by it.
Looking strictly at the motoring accidents due to driving errrors , the vast majority of them occur when the driver is between 18 and 30; should we call for banning all individuals in that age-band !! Various research studies have been carried out in different parts of the world , mainly in western countries and in the majority older drivers have come out better. They usually drive within their 'limits', use known routes avoiding difficult crossings /roundabouts or junctions at busy times and if with some visual difficulties avoid driving at night. They also drive more responsibly with care and attention , behave much better to other fellow motorists , adhere to the highway codes and do not use mobile phones whilst driving! Of course things are bound to go wrong sometime - and there will take place some odd human errors in judgement.
Let us now look at the overall social consequence of older people NOT allowed to drive. Who will take them to supermarkets ( after all most of the local corner shops have closed now), to the town centre post office ( a large number of small post offices have also been shut), to the Banks or simply to visit friends and relatives to socialise? Will those individuals calling for such a 'driving ban' accompany them giving lifts to all those areas ? Will the state provide suitable transport from their door-step? How much additional 'dependency' would that generate and its overall costs?
Whilst all sensible people are deperately trying to keep the elderly 'independent' for as long as possible, is this 'driving ban for over 75s' a sensible proposal on grounds of proper evidence? Let us leave it to the motoring insurers.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article